2.1. DFT Calculations
We first employed DFT calculations to explore the effect of NH
4+ incorporation on the electrochemical properties of vanadium-based cathode materials, focusing particularly on the charge transfer interactions involving Zn
2+ ions. Two computational models were meticulously optimized: Zn
2+ incorporated into V
6O
16 (referred to as Zn-VO) and Zn
2+ incorporated into (NH
4)
2V
6O
16 (referred to as Zn-NHVO), with the results depicted in
Figure 1a,b.
The charge density difference calculations for these models provide crucial insights into the electrostatic interactions within the cathode materials. In the Zn-VO model, a significant charge transfer is observed between Zn
2+ and the oxygen atoms in the V-O bonds (as shown in
Figure 1a). This charge transfer manifests as a reduction in charge density near Zn
2+, depicted in blue, and an increase in surrounding regions, shown in yellow. The interaction leads to a strong electrostatic attraction between Zn
2+ and the lattice oxygen, which impedes the diffusion of Zn
2+. This strong interaction not only hinders the mobility of Zn
2+ within the cathode but also contributes to structural instability during battery cycling, potentially leading to material degradation and collapse.
Conversely, in the Zn-NHVO model, the introduction of NH
4+ modifies the interaction landscape dramatically. Here, the primary charge transfer occurs between Zn
2+ and NH
4+ ions, significantly reducing the direct electrostatic interactions between Zn
2+ and the lattice framework of the cathode material. The presence of NH
4+ mitigates the intensity of the electrostatic fields experienced by Zn
2+ ions, thereby facilitating smoother ion diffusion, as evidenced by the yellow regions in
Figure 1b, which denote an increase in charge density. This alteration suggests that NH
4+ acts effectively as a ”lubricant”, enhancing the mobility of Zn
2+ through the cathode material and improving the structural stability during the electrochemical cycling process.
These findings underscore the potential of NH4+ as a strategic additive for enhancing the performance of vanadium-based cathode materials. By altering the charge distribution and reducing detrimental interactions within the cathode, NH4+ inclusion leads to improved ion diffusion capabilities and increased material stability.
2.2. Morphological Characterization
To verify the results from the DFT calculations, we synthesized NHVO using a one-step hydrothermal method and characterized it using X-ray Powder Diffraction (XRD) and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR). The XRD patterns, shown in
Figure 2a,b, predominantly exhibit diffraction peaks that align well with those of (NH
4)
2V
6O
16 (JCPDS No. 22-1046, space group: P2
1/m), indicating the successful synthesis of the material.
The crystal structure of NHVO, depicted in
Figure 2c, consists of alternating chains of VO
5 pyramids and VO
6 octahedra, which are interconnected through shared vertices and edges. This arrangement supports a layered structure, with ammonium ions acting as ‘pillars’ that stabilize the framework.
Further confirmation of the synthesized NHVO’s structural integrity was provided through FTIR analysis, represented in
Figure 2d. The observed peaks at 736 cm
−1 and 525 cm
−1 are attributed to the asymmetric and symmetric stretching vibrations of V–O bonds, respectively. Peaks at 967 cm
−1 and 1003 cm
−1 correspond to the stretching vibrations of V
4+=O and V
5+=O in the VO
5 pyramids and VO
6 octahedra, indicating the presence of both vanadium oxidation states, which are critical to the material’s functionality. Additionally, the peaks at 3215 cm
−1 and 1402 cm
−1 are identified as the asymmetric stretching and symmetric bending vibrations of N–H bonds, further confirming the successful incorporation of ammonium ions within the layered structure.
The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images (
Figure 3a,b) of NHVO reveal its unique surface morphology characterized by uneven, overlap** nanosheets with a distinctly wrinkled texture. This morphology is particularly advantageous for cathode materials in AZIBs, as the high surface area facilitates Zn
2+ intercalation and deintercalation, enhancing the electrochemical performance and ion diffusion kinetics. The wrinkled surfaces can potentially increase the electrode–electrolyte contact area, promoting better ion transfer and accessibility, which are critical for high-rate performance in batteries. Energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) map** (
Figure 3c) complements the SEM analysis by confirming the homogeneous distribution of nitrogen (N), V, and oxygen (O) within the nanosheets. This uniformity in the elemental composition ensures consistent electrochemical behavior across the electrode, which is essential for achieving stable cycling performance in AZIBs.
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images (
Figure 4) provide a closer look at the overlap** nanosheet morphology, further verifying the nanoscale features observed in the SEM images. The TEM analysis supports the structural details by showcasing the thin, layered nature of the nanosheets, which is ideal for facilitating short diffusion paths for zinc-ions. This structural confirmation through TEM indicates a well-synthesized material with characteristics that are supportive of its application as a cathode material in AZIBs.
2.3. Electrochemical Properties Characterization
The electrochemical performance of NHVO as a cathode material in AZIBs was rigorously evaluated through small current cycle performance tests, rate capability tests, and high current cycle tests. Vanadium-based compounds often exhibit poor cycle stability under low current densities due to the more thorough and slower reactions occurring on the electrode, which challenge the structural integrity of the material. Remarkably, NHVO demonstrates a unique behavior under such conditions.
Initially, at a low current density of 0.2 A g
−1, NHVO displayed a modest capacity. However, as cycling progressed, the capacity gradually increased, indicating an activation process and stabilization of the electrode material. This was clearly demonstrated in the test results, where NHVO exhibited excellent cycling stability and Coulombic efficiency with no capacity fade over 100 cycles, as shown in
Figure 5a. This suggests that NHVO, unlike typical vanadium-based materials, maintains structural integrity even under slow, exhaustive reaction conditions, which is critical for long-term applications in batteries.
Upon the activation of the electrode material at low currents, rate capability tests were conducted at varied current densities of 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.5, 1, 2, and 5 A g
−1 (
Figure 5b). The specific capacities observed were 246.8, 242.6, 239.7, 229.8, 221.3, 202.2, and 170 mAh g
−1, respectively. Notably, when the current density was reverted to 0.1 A g
−1, the capacity recovered to 253.7 mAh g
−1, highlighting the excellent reversibility and structural resilience of NHVO. These results, consistent with DFT calculations, confirm the predictive accuracy of DFT in assessing the structural stability and electrochemical behavior of NHVO.
Furthermore, NHVO demonstrated robust performance under high-current-density tests. After full activation at high currents, NHVO sustained a capacity of 157.1 mAh g
−1 over 500 cycles at a current density of 2 A g
−1, with a Coulombic efficiency approaching 100%, as depicted in
Figure 5c. This performance underlines the feasibility of NHVO as a cathode material for AZIBs, showcasing its capability to handle significant electrochemical stresses without substantial degradation.
Moreover, as depicted in
Figure 5a,c, the capacity of the NHVO cathode material exhibits an initial increase up to the 40th cycle at a current density of 0.2 A g
−1, subsequently followed by a decline. The initial capacity enhancement from 0 to 40 cycles can be primarily attributed to the activation of the NHVO cathode material. During these initial cycles, electrochemical activation facilitates the enhancement of active site accessibility and improves the wettability of the electrode, thereby temporarily augmenting the capacity. Beyond the 40th cycle, the capacity progressively diminishes. This reduction can be principally ascribed to the dissolution of active material into the electrolyte. Furthermore, the repetitive intercalation and deintercalation of Zn
2+ ions induce volumetric changes in the cathode material, which in turn generate mechanical stress and lead to a loss of electrical contact within the electrode structure.
Galvanostatic charge–discharge tests were conducted on NHVO within a voltage range of 0.2–1.6 V at a constant current density of 0.2 A g
−1, as depicted in
Figure 6a. Initially, the discharge capacity was observed at 34.5 mAh g
−1, followed by a charge capacity of 25.7 mAh g
−1. With successive cycles, the electrode demonstrated gradual activation, leading to an increase in both discharge and charge capacities along with the formation of extended and stable electrochemical plateaus. Notably, the discharge profiles displayed significant plateaus at 0.9 V and 0.6 V. This behavior underlines the excellent electrochemical reversibility of NHVO, with average discharge and charge capacities stabilizing around 200.1 mAh g
−1 and 200.3 mAh g
−1 respectively, as illustrated in
Figure 6a.
Further testing at a high current density of 5 A g
−1 over 2000 cycles, as depicted in
Figure 6b, showcased remarkable cycle stability and consistency in the charge–discharge profiles. This sustained performance, coupled with a high Coulombic efficiency of 99.9%, indicates that the (de)intercalation of Zn
2+ ions within NHVO is highly reversible. These findings reinforce the predictions made by DFT calculations, highlighting the material’s robustness and efficiency under demanding conditions.
During the long cycling test at 5 A g
−1, although the initial specific capacity was relatively low, it stabilized significantly upon full activation, maintaining a capacity of 141.8 mAh g
−1. After 2000 cycles, the capacity retention was impressively high at 94%, as shown in
Figure 6c. This endurance, especially under high current conditions, suggests that NHVO possesses exceptional structural stability and can endure the stresses of rapid charge and discharge processes without significant degradation.
Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) was employed to characterize the impedance properties of NHVO over the frequency range of 0.01 Hz to 100,000 Hz. As depicted in
Figure 7, the impedance spectra for NHVO are composed of a semicircle in the low-frequency region and a linear “tail” in the high-frequency region. These features can be interpreted as indicative of two primary electrochemical processes: charge transfer and mass transfer. The charge transfer resistance (
Rct) and the Warburg impedance (
Zw), which abstract these processes, are key parameters in analyzing the electrode dynamics.
In the EIS spectrum, the semicircle at higher frequencies corresponds to Rct, whereas the linear part at lower frequencies is associated with Zw, which models the diffusion of ions within the electrode material. In practical terms, the impedance due to Warburg effects is considered negligible at very low frequencies (close to zero impedance) and becomes significant at higher frequencies.
Initially, the EIS measurements revealed a relatively high Rct for the NHVO cathode. This heightened initial resistance can be attributed to the pristine state of the electrode material, where electron conduction pathways are suboptimal, and the electrode/electrolyte interfaces are not fully established.
Upon subsequent cycling, particularly after 100 cycles at a low current regime, a notable reduction in
Rct was observed. This decrease suggests several advantageous modifications to the electrode’s microstructure and chemistry induced by the cycling process. First, the application of electrical stress during cycling promotes the formation of new, more efficient pathways for electron conduction [
43]. Such pathways often arise through minor restructuring of the electrode material, which may include the formation of micro-cracks or other microstructural rearrangements that diminish barriers to electron mobility.
Moreover, the repeated intercalation and deintercalation of ions during cycling contribute to a more activated state of the electrode surface. This electrochemical activation aids in reducing polarization at the electrode/electrolyte interface, thereby enhancing the kinetics of the involved electrochemical reactions. These alterations generally coincide with an increase in electrical conductivity and a reduction in overall resistance to charge transfer within the electrode material.
Additionally, the cycling process facilitates the partial exfoliation of layered materials within the electrode, exposing fresher, more reactive surfaces that enhance electrochemical reactivity and charge transfer efficiency. This characteristic of electrode behavior under cycling conditions is pivotal for applications demanding high durability and efficiency over prolonged usage, such as in batteries and supercapacitors.
In summary, the observed post-cycling decrease in Rct is primarily attributable to the formation of efficient electron conduction pathways and the activation of the electrode material. These changes collectively improve the electrochemical performance of the NHVO cathode.
2.4. Storage Mechanism of Zn2+
Cyclic voltammetry (CV) tests were conducted on NHVO to elucidate the Zn
2+ storage mechanism within this cathode material for aqueous AZIBs. The tests were performed at a scan rate of 0.1 mV s
−1 across a voltage range of 0.2–1.6 V (relative to Zn
2+/Zn), as shown in
Figure 8a. The initial three cycles revealed two distinct pairs of redox peaks around 0.52/0.71 V and 0.85/1.05 V, indicative of the intercalation/deintercalation of Zn
2+ ions within the NHVO host material. These observations suggest a multi-step reaction mechanism, which is typical for materials where multiple valence states facilitate the storage process.
Notably, a slight shift in the redox peaks was observed from the very first cycle, suggesting an initial activation of the cathode. This transition reflects changes in the electrode’s surface properties or the formation of new active sites, enhancing the electrochemical reactivity. The overlap** nature of the subsequent cycles indicates good reversibility in the Zn2+ intercalation/deintercalation process within the layers of NHVO. This reversible behavior is crucial for the long-term stability and efficiency of the battery.
The presence of well-defined redox peaks also underscores the potential for phase transitions within the NHVO structure, facilitated by the cycling process. The consistent appearance of these peaks in subsequent cycles suggests that the NHVO structure accommodates the Zn2+ without significant degradation or structural collapse. This stability in the redox behavior across cycles highlights the robustness of NHVO as a cathode material, capable of sustaining repeated electrochemical processes essential for high-performance zinc-ion batteries.
The CV curves of NHVO electrodes at different scan rates, depicted in
Figure 8b, provide crucial insights into the electrochemical behavior and Zn
2+ storage mechanisms of the NHVO cathode material in aqueous zinc-ion batteries. Analyzing the relationship between the current (
i) and scan rate (
v) offers a method for qualitatively assessing the contributions of capacitive effects using Equations (1) and (2):
Here, the exponent
b is a pivotal factor that distinguishes the controlling electrochemical processes. Values of
b close to 0.5 typically suggest a predominance of ionic diffusion, whereas values nearing 1.0 indicate control by capacitive behavior. The
b values calculated from the peak currents, specifically for peaks 1–4, were found to be 0.82, 0.81, 0.77, and 0.82, respectively (see
Figure 8c). These values reveal that the electrochemical reactions are controlled by a combination of capacitive and diffusion behaviors.
Moreover, the respective currents at different scan rates can be described by Equation (3):
In this model,
k1v and
k2v1/2 represent the contributions from capacitive processes and diffusion-controlled processes, respectively. For instance, in
Figure 8d (at 0.1 mV s
−1), the green area signifies the capacitive contribution, and the remainder of the CV curve indicates diffusion control. This depiction aligns with the pseudo-capacitive contributions calculated at various scan rates, as outlined in
Figure 9, with values of 62%, 67%, 73%, 73.5%, 80.6%, and 84.4% at scan rates of 0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 1 mV s
−1 respectively. At lower scan rates, the electrochemical behavior is predominantly influenced by ionic diffusion, whereas at higher scan rates, capacitive processes increasingly dominate, playing a more crucial role in the electrochemistry of the NHVO electrodes.
To further investigate the electrochemical reaction mechanisms within the Zn/NHVO battery, the galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT) was employed to analyze the diffusion dynamics of Zn
2+ ions after 1000 charge–discharge cycles, as depicted in
Figure 10a. The GITT experiments were systematically conducted, involving a series of pulse applications followed by operation under a constant current and concluding with a relaxation period. A current density of 0.1 A g
−1 was maintained throughout the experiments. The relaxation period was set to 30 min, and measurements were recorded at intervals of 10 s. The calculation is based on the following equation:
where
τ represents the relaxation time,
mB is the mass of active material,
VM denotes the molar volume,
MB is the molar mass,
S is the surface area of the electrode, and Δ
ES and Δ
Et are the steady-state and transient potential changes, respectively. This analytical approach yielded a diffusion coefficient for Zn
2+ ions ranging from 10
−11 to 10
−10 cm
2 s
−1. These values are significantly superior to those reported for several other vanadium-based cathode materials in AZIBs, underscoring the enhanced diffusion properties of the novel NHVO material.
The consistent observation of
DZn2+ values throughout the entire GITT cycle, shown in
Figure 10b, confirms the robust and reliable diffusion characteristics of the NHVO material. A high diffusion coefficient is indicative of the material’s capacity to facilitate rapid Zn
2+ ion transport, which is critical for achieving excellent rate performance. This feature is essential in applications requiring a high power output and efficient energy delivery, particularly under rapid charge and discharge conditions.
Furthermore, the preservation of high DZn2+ values after 1000 cycles points to the structural stability and integrity of the NHVO material. This stability suggests that the NHVO electrode maintains effective ion pathways and a crystalline structure, despite undergoing repeated intercalation and deintercalation processes of Zn2+ ions. Such durability is crucial for the long-term usability and cycle life of zinc-ion batteries, reinforcing the potential of NHVO as a superior cathode material.
In addition, ex situ XRD and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analyses were employed to probe the electrochemical mechanisms of NHVO. These techniques were utilized to examine the electrode materials cycled over a voltage range of 0.2 to 1.6 V for 100 cycles to ensure full activation. Following activation, the electrodes were analyzed at the discharged state of 0.2 V and the charged state of 1.6 V.
The XRD patterns, displayed in
Figure 11a,b, covering the 5–80° and 25–80° ranges respectively, show that the primary diffraction peaks maintain their positions across the cycling process. This observation implies that the crystal structure of NHVO remains relatively stable, with no significant phase transitions occurring during cycling. The stability in peak positions is indicative of the robustness of NHVO under operational conditions, highlighting its suitability for long-term applications in battery technology. During the discharge to 0.2 V, new peaks appear, as seen in
Figure 11b, which correspond to the formation of an intermediate phase, identified as Zn
3(OH)
2V
2O
7·2H
2O. The appearance of these peaks suggests the involvement of water molecules in the structural matrix of NHVO, which could be critical for the intercalation mechanism of Zn
2+ ions.
Significantly, the peak at approximately 12°, corresponding to the (001) planes of NHVO, shifts slightly leftwards when discharged to 0.2 V, indicative of an increase in the interlayer spacing. This alteration can be attributed to the intercalation of Zn2+ ions, which enlarge the layer spacing to accommodate their size. Upon recharging to 1.6 V, the original peak position is restored, demonstrating the reversible nature of this intercalation process.
Figure 11c–e display the XPS patterns for Zn, V, and O elements in the NHVO electrodes at various stages: the pristine electrode, discharged to 0.2 V after three cycles, and recharged to 1.6 V. Initially, the pristine NHVO electrode displayed no detectable Zn signals, which is expected, as Zn is not a constituent of the virgin material. Upon discharging to 0.2 V, a prominent Zn 2p
3/2 peak was observed at 1022.58 eV, indicating the intercalation of Zn
2+ ions into the electrode matrix. This peak, however, diminished in intensity but remained visible at 1022.4 eV when the electrode was fully recharged to 1.6 V, suggesting some degree of irreversible Zn
2+ intercalation during the electrode activation process.
For vanadium, the XPS spectra revealed binding energies at 516.2 eV and 517.8 eV, corresponding to the V2p3/2 peaks of V4+ and V5+ states, respectively. Notably, the proportion of V4+ increased after the third full discharge, a change attributed to the reductive reaction occurring at the cathode due to Zn2+ insertion. This proportion decreased upon full recharge, indicating a reversible oxidation–reduction process linked with the electrochemical cycling of the electrode.
The oxygen 1s spectrum for the NHVO electrode, which can be deconvoluted into three peaks at 530.18, 531.8, and 533.68 eV, corresponds to lattice oxygen in V=O bonds, hydroxyl groups (OH−), and water (H2O), respectively. The proportion of water-associated signals increased significantly during the discharge cycle, which benefits the electrochemical dynamics by providing the electrostatic shielding of metal ions, enhancing ion mobility and thus improving the kinetics of the electrochemical reactions and high-rate performance capabilities. The full reversibility of these peaks after charging indicates the good reversibility of the NHVO electrodes.
Figure 12 schematically illustrates the structural changes within the electrode during cycling. Initially, during the first discharge where Zn
2+ irreversibly intercalates, Zn
2+ and H
2O incorporation into the NHVO interlayers results in an expansion of the adjacent VO layers. This leads to a partial transformation of NHVO into Zn
x(NH
4)
yV
6O
16·zH
2O and Zn
3(OH)
2V
2O
7·2H
2O. In subsequent cycles, both phases coexist with reversible intercalation and deintercalation of Zn
2+, exhibiting high reversibility consistent with the previous literature.